All of the ice cream here at Calabash Creamery is made with only the best ingredients.  We take pride in the fact that we use natural flavorings and fresh fruit for all of our ice cream creations. We serve 24 flavors of our homemade ice cream, including two No Sugar Added flavors, and one sherbet flavor. Some flavors are Seasonal items. Come in and try one of our unique flavor creations! We know once you try our ice cream, you will be hooked. Here is a list of many of our flavors that we rotate through.

Homemade Ice Cream Flavours

Baileys Irish Cream
A St. Patrick’s Day Favorite! Tastes great with a cup of coffee.

Banana’s Foster
Our fresh banana ice cream with a kick.

Banana Pudding
Fresh Banana’s with crushed “Nilla” wafers make this ice cream as good as its inspiration!

Banana Split
Banana base with strawberry, pineapple and chocolate streak. We decorate the pan with dollops of whipped cream, cherries and peanuts.

Better then Almond Joy
Ever freeze an Almond Joy candy bar? This is better, with lots of coconut and chocolate covered almonds.

Birthday Cake
Just as it says! Tastes just like it, with real cake pieces. We decorate the pan with our cake icing and colorful decorates.

Black Cherry
Ground black cherries and half cherries make up this classic.

Black Raspberry
Ground black raspberries make a delicious cool treat..

Bubble Gum
A kid’s favorite!

Butter Pecan
Our #1 seller! Creamy with lots of locally grown pecans.

Candy Galore
A blend of all of our favorite Halloween candies mixed in vanilla ice cream. 

Cantaloupe
Our flavor of the month! Make with fresh cantaloupe and a strawberry swirl.

Cappuccino Crunch
The great taste of our signature coffee ice cream with the added sweetness of crushed heath bar candies mixed in.

Caramel Cashew (no sugar added)
A true favorite.! A caramel case with a caramel swirl and pleanty of cashews.

Cherry Vanilla
Sweet, plump cherries mixed with our classic vanilla ice cream

Chocolate
Rich, Creamy, Smooth!

Chocolate Chip
Our classic vanilla with lots of chocolate flakes.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Our chocolate base mixed with Peanut Butter and ground Reeses® Peanut Butter cups.

Cinnamon
Great cinnamon Flavor. Perfect on top of apple pie!

Cinnamon Bun
Cinnamon ice cream with chopped cinnamon buns mixed in.

Coffee
A creamy blend of vanilla and real coffee make this a crowd pleaser.

Cookies and Cream
Our vanilla with crushed Oreo’s®

Cotton Candy
Just like you were at the fair!

Cow-A-Bash Crunch
A white chocolate base with chocolate cake crunch. We decorate the pan in cow Print. Our signature flavor!

Dutch Chocolate
A sweet mild chocolate

Dulcede Leche
An Italian favorite, “Pure Caramel Bliss”.

Egg Nog
The holidays wouldn’t be the same without!

Fudge Brownie Sundae
Vanilla base with a fudge swirl and brownie bites.

Fudge Ripple (no sugars added)
A fudge lovers dream!

German Chocolate Cake
A creamy German chocolate and coconut! We decorate the pan with coconut flakes mixed with caramel.

Ginger Snap
Just like the cookie!

Granny’s Apple Pie
Just like Grandma used to make!

Key Lime Pie
Fresh key lime juice with graham crunch mixed in. So rich and creamy. Takes you to the tropics.

Mango Sherbet
Pureed mangos make this a refreshing choice.

Mango Tango
A “dance” of mango ice cream and pineapple chunks.

Maple Walnut
Superb maple syrup background with lots of walnuts.

Mint Chocolate Chip
Mint flavor with mint

Mocha Chip (no sugars added)
Our creamy coffee ice cream filled with dark chocolate chips.

New York Cheesecake
A wonderful blend of real Philadelphia cream cheese and sweet graham crunchies. Great combined with any of our premium fruit or fudge toppings.

Peanut Butter and Jelly
Just like the sandwich! Peanut Butter ice cream with tons of Smucker’s grape jelly. A favorite of young and old.

Peppermint Patty
Peppermint ice cream with dark chocolate chips. If you froze a York Peppermint Patty and ate it, it would taste like this ice cream.

Peppermint Stick
A must at Christmas! We crush candy canes to mix with our peppermint ice cream.

Pineapple Sherbet
A cold treat on a hot summer day. Light and refreshing make from pure pineapple juice.

Pistachio
A classic flavor make with roasted pistachio nuts.

Plantation Praline
A southern tradition. Sweet caramel ice cream loaded with praline rolled pecans.

Pumpkin Pie
A Thanksgiving tradition. Take one bite and you will think your back in Grandma’s kitchen.

Red Raspberry Chip
Red raspberry ice cream with dark chocolate chips make this ice cream a great combination of sweet and tart.

Rocky Road
A traditional flavor of chocolate ice cream loaded with mini marshmallows and peanuts.

Rum Raisin
A great winter flavor loaded with sweet, plump raisins.

Smores
A blend of marshmallow ice cream with crushed graham crackers and chocolate chips will take you right back to the camp fire.

Strawberry
Made with fresh strawberries – locally grown when available.

Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry swirled ice cream with real cake pieces.

Sunset Peach
Named for the popular neighborhood town. Made with fresh local peaches.

Sweet Potato Souffle
If you like sweet potato pie – you’ll love our S.P.S. Made with sweet potato’s, brown sugar and just the right amount of cinnamon and praline pecans.

Swiss Chocolate Almond
Sweet, creamy chocolate with slivered almonds.

Thin Mint®
Made from popular girl scout cookies.

Tin Roof Sundae
A creamy blend of our classic vanilla ice cream, fudge and peanuts.

Tirimisu
The distinct taste of our favorite Italian dessert all wrapped up in our creamy delicious ice cream.

Turtle Cheesecake
A blend of rich caramel, chocolate chips, pecans,  and real cream cheese make this a favorite for all.

Turtle Trax
Inspired be the local sea turtles, this ice cream is make with a graham cracker base, rich caramel, chocolate chips and pecans.

Vanilla
The old time favorite – made with Madagascar Bourbon two fold.

White Cherri
A Christmas time favorite with white chocolate and black cherries.

Seasonal Flavours

May:

Fresh Strawberry Sundays & Milkshakes

June:

Fresh Cantaloupe Ice Cream

July:

Fresh Peach Sundays & Shakes, Sunset Peach Ice Cream


New "DOLE*-LICIOUS" Soft Serve ice cream

* 100 calories per/ 4oz. serving
* low fat
* low cholesterol
* non-dairy/ lactose free

Available in variety of fresh fruit flavors!